Why but How

This video is a philosophical monologue exploring the practical methods and mindset required to effectively engage in the process of asking “why.” The speaker treats “why” as a verb—an active inquiry—and moves beyond the simple advice to be curious, focusing instead on how to balance questioning with action, patience, and self-awareness.

The Problem: Not Just “Why,” But “How”
#

[00:00:32] The video argues that simply being told to “ask why” is not enough. The key challenge is learning how to engage with this process, which includes knowing when not to ask why. This creates a “higher order why” about the nature of questioning itself.

[00:01:22] This involves an intricate balance between asking “why” and deciding “why not why” at a particular moment. The goal is to move from seeking absolute answers to engaging with a more abstract, higher-order inquiry about your questions.

Balancing Inquiry with Action
#

[00:03:30] The speaker emphasizes that thinking alone is insufficient. True cognitive evolution comes from balancing inquiry with taking action and collecting real-world experiences. This process helps you update and refine the “gauge” with which you approach your questions.

[00:04:12] This balance is especially crucial when making difficult, customized life decisions, such as choosing between two equally good options where the best choice depends on your personal context.

Strategies for “How to Why”
#

The speaker outlines several practical strategies for managing the process of inquiry.

1. Document Your Thinking
#

[00:05:42] Journaling and Video Essays: Use tools like journaling or creating videos to document the trajectory of your thoughts. This isn’t about finding an immediate answer but creating a commentary on the question itself.
[00:08:37] This form of logging helps you track how your perspective on a question evolves over time.

2. Break Down the “Why”
#

[00:09:25] Top-Down Breakdown: Instead of tackling one massive “why,” break it down into a collection of smaller “sub-whys.”
[00:10:07] This process helps clarify your priorities, as some sub-questions will be more obvious or important to address in the moment, creating a clear path forward.

3. Practice Patience and “Queuing”
#

[00:11:38] Patience is Key: The speaker notes that he once believed any question could be solved with raw intellectual force. He learned that many complex, personal questions need time to “simmer.”
[00:12:53] The “Queue of Whys”: Treat your questions like a queue. Pick one, break it down, solve what you can, and re-queue the parts that need more time or experience to answer.
[00:13:51] It’s normal for the queue of questions to grow faster than you can answer them. The goal is progress, not an empty queue.

4. Use Forgetting as a Tool
#

[00:15:32] The Value of Forgetting: Forgetting a question is a natural filter. If a question is truly important, it will resurface on its own.
[00:28:49] When a forgotten question re-emerges naturally, its importance is validated without you having to force it. This is a more authentic way to assign priority than simply writing it down.

5. Navigate Paradoxes and “Hypocrisy”
#

[00:16:10] Embrace Paradox: The world is filled with paradoxes where multiple contradictory answers can seem true.
[00:19:11] Contextual Morality: The speaker discusses learning to hold opposing viewpoints, which some might call being a “hypocrite.” He frames this as an adaptive skill and a sign of maturity.
[00:21:57] Being able to cognitively embody both sides of an issue allows you to understand the true value and context of your own stance.
[00:20:34] As an example, the speaker “enqueues” a new question for himself during the video: how to be okay with being a hypocrite?

The Cost of Serendipity
#

[00:27:22] The ability to have these spontaneous, insightful thoughts (“serendipity”) is not effortless. The speaker argues that serendipity is expensive, requiring a long-term investment of continuous thought and engagement over months and years.

Conclusion
#

[00:29:45] The video concludes by framing the process of “how to why” as a skill developed through a toolbox of mental models. Key takeaways include the importance of patience, the utility of forgetting as a filter, and the maturity required to navigate paradoxes. Engaging with questions in this structured yet flexible manner can trigger a chain reaction of thought and lead to a more resolved and self-aware life.